Portfolio A1 Performance Update: 5/31/08

Since I continue to receive inquiries about Portfolio A1 as well as my new subscriber newsletter model portfolios, I thought I would provide a snapshot of the portfolios at the end of each month.

The chart below shows the equity curve and some summary statistics for Portfolio A1 since the portfolio (which is equities only, long only) was created on February 16, 2007. During the 15 ½ months since inception, Portfolio A1 has posted a cumulative return (exclusive of dividends) of 19.8%, while the benchmark S&P 500 index has declined 3.8%.

The graphic to the right provides some additional performance details for Portfolio A1 vs. the S&P 500 index over a variety of time frames.

For the record, Portfolio A1’s current holdings include: Mosaic (MOS); TBS International (TBSI); PetroQuest (PQ); World Acceptance (WRLD); and Brasil Telecom Participacoes (BRP). Portfolio A1 also shares some common ancestry and has a stock ranking system that is similar to the VIX and More Focus Aggressive Trader model portfolio – one of the four model portfolios that I update transaction by transaction for newsletter subscribers. At some point later this weekend, I will provide some details about the performance of the subscriber newsletter portfolios.

Finally, I would be remiss in not reiterating that Portfolio A1 was created with tools developed by Portfolio123.com and is managed via Portfolio123.com’s tool set. For more information on Portfolio123.com, please refer to an earlier post on the subject, Portfolio123.com: The Engine Behind Portfolio A1. [For the record, I have no affiliation with Portfolio123.com]

Brazil Rallies While China Struggles

As the chart below shows, speculative money has been cautious about China since late October, but still bullish on Brazil, as indicated by the strong performance in EWZ, the iShares MSCI Brazil Index ETF. Not only is EWZ showing a gain for the year, but in an impressive display of strength, it has rallied more than 30% off of the January low. This performance puts EWZ not only well ahead of the most popular Chinese ETF, FXI, but also considerably ahead of the broad market emerging market ETF, EEM, known formally as the iShares MSCI Emerging Markets Index.

While EWZ is a great way to play the Brazilian market, there are several ADRs that are worth singling out as well. My Portfolio A1 holds Tele Norte Leste Participacoes SA (TNE) and has also been long Brasil Telecom Participacoes SA (BRP) in recent months, but there are even better plays. In fact, of the handful of long-term global holdings that I believe you could almost buy and forget about, two of my favorites are Brazilian giants. At the top of the list is Petroleo Brasileiro SA (PBR), a.k.a. Petrobras, the superbly managed national oil company that is pushing the envelope in the ultra-deep recovery space with their massive Tupi oilfield. Close behind is Vale (RIO), formerly know as Companhia Vale do Rio Doce, the metals and mining giant that recently extracted a 65% price increase in iron ore prices from Baosteel, the largest steel company in China.

In a healthy global economy, PBR and RIO are two of the best blue chip oil and iron plays out there. For those wishing a broader, more diversified play, EWZ is hard to beat, especially as Brazil continues to outpace China.

Portfolio A1 Falls as Mosaic’s Run Comes to an End

It was fun while it lasted, but it had to come to an end eventually. The Mosaic Company (MOS), which had run up an eye opening 176% in the first five months it was in Portfolio A1, is now gone from stable, victim of a rule that automatically culls any stock that falls 20% from the high recorded during the holding period. Also shown the door as a result of a 20% drop is Brazil Telecom Participacoes (BRP).

Replacing MOS and BRP are LG Philips LCD Co. (LPL) and Terra Industries (TRA). LG Philips LCD Co. is a Seoul-based $16 billion joint venture in the display business between two global giants, LG Electronics and Royal Philips Electronics. TRA, a nitrogen fertilizer company, demonstrates how some portfolio ‘rules’ can backfire, as this company is a direct competitor of Mosaic in the fertilizer business and at only 10% of Mosaic’s market capitalization is actually a much riskier play in this sector. Nevertheless, the stock ranker has spoken and TRA should do well if this week turns out to be a bottom. As far as the wisdom of holding an LCD manufacturer at a point where consumer demand appears to be drying up, I am skeptical, but this remains a 100% mechanical portfolio, where my perspective does not matter.

After falling 11.4% last week, Portfolio A1 is still sporting a 5% gain since the February 16, 2007 inception, considerably better than the 9% loss in the benchmark S&P 500 index during the same period.

There no other changes to the portfolio this week.

A snapshot of the Portfolio A1 is as follows:

Portfolio A1 Makes Big Bet on Brazilian Telecoms to Start Year

For the first time in awhile, Portfolio A1 gave back some ground to the benchmark S&P 500 index last week. Even with last week’s sub-par performance, since the February 16, 2007 inception, Portfolio A1 now has a cumulative gain of 20.7%, compared to a 3.7% loss for the SPX.

After falling 7% last week, Sinopec, a.k.a. China Petroleum & Chemical Corp (SNP) has been dropped from the portfolio, victim of a rule whereby a position is automatically closed once it falls 20% from its high during the ownership period. Also dropped were Norwegian energy and aluminum giant Norsk Hydro (NHYDY), but in this instance as a result of a declining rank from the stock ranking system. The ranking system partly reflects several technical factors and picked up on the fact that NHYDY’s stock has also struggled and is down about 17% for the first two weeks of 2008.

Replacing SNP and NHYDY in the portfolio are returnee Fresh Del Monte Produce (FDP) and a second Brazilian telecom company: Tele Norte Leste Participacoes (TNE), an integrated fixed line and mobile telecom provider with a $9.5 billion market cap. TNE joins long-time favorite BRP to give Portfolio A1 an unusual mix of 2/5 Brazilian telecoms in this five-legged portfolio. By design a focused five stock portfolio is intended to make significant bets in specific sectors and regions, but it is unusual to find this type of concentration in the portfolio, which uses a maximum sector weighting of 30% to place sector limits on all new purchases. The reason there are currently two telecom companies in the portfolio is that Mosaic (MOS) has had such a strong run (up 175.7%) that it now comprises 42% of the portfolio, so that it is possible for the other four holdings to split the remaining 58% with two companies in one sector that do not total to 30%.

Note that the portfolio has no provision for limiting the concentration of holdings by country or region.

There no other changes to the portfolio this week.

A snapshot of Portfolio A1 is as follows:

Portfolio A1 Begins 2008 By Increasing Gap on SPX

While the first three trading days of 2008 knocked 0.8% off of the value of Portfolio A1, this was much better than the 3.9% loss in the benchmark S&P 500 index. Since the February 16, 2007 inception, Portfolio A1 now stands with a gain of 21%, in contrast to a 3% loss for the SPX.

Brasil Telecom Participacoes S.A. (BRP) was the only stock in the portfolio that advanced during the week, bucking the downtrend in US-based technology stocks.

There no changes to the portfolio this week.

A snapshot of Portfolio A1 is as follows:

Mosaic (MOS) Continues to Lead Portfolio A1

The title is probably a considerable understatement, but what else can you say about a stock that is up 91% in only ten weeks in the portfolio?

The amazing run of The Mosaic Company (MOS) has helped to push Portfolio A1’s performance to a cumulative return of 14.15% since the portfolio inception on February 16, 2007. This is 8.67% better than the 5.48% returned by the benchmark S&P 500 index during the period.

Mosaic’s performance has triggered a number of thoughts about portfolio design, backtesting, and the likelihood of catching lightning in a bottle. Simply stated, in the 8 ½ months that Portfolio A1 has been up and running, it has purchased 27 stocks. Almost half of these stocks are up 50% during this period and 30% (MOS, DRYS, BRP, PCU, PBR, RIO, CNH, and SNDA) are up an astonishing 100% or more. The bottom line is that I believe it is possible identify stocks that have a high likelihood of doubling or tripling in one year (with attendant risk, of course) and build portfolio rules to maximize the probability of capturing those gains during the time they are held in one’s portfolio. I will expand upon this going forward, but Portfolio A1 should provide some evidence to support that contention.

There is one change to the portfolio: Navistar International (NAVZ) has been dropped and is being replaced by returnee PepsiAmerican (PAS), the beverage bottler. There are no other changes to the portfolio this week.

A snapshot of the portfolio is as follows:

Portfolio A1 Appears to Find a Bottom

After four weeks of performance that you wouldn’t want to be downwind of, it seems appropriate that it took a new addition to the portfolio – and a fertilizer company at that – to turn around Portfolio A1. The fertilizer company, Mosaic (MOS), surged 14% last week, while the other portfolio newcomer, agricultural equipment maker CNH Global (CNH) posted a weekly return of 5.7%. For now at least, the agricultural theme is working.

The aggregate portfolio statistics are still on the ugly side, with the portfolio down 12% since the February 16^th inception, well behind the benchmark S&P 500’s 1.6% gain during the same period. With a Sharpe ratio of -0.72, a winning percentage of 36%, and a maximum drawdown of 29.9%, one has to look long and hard to find a silver lining in the portfolio’s performance. Still, I will ride this portfolio out through the end of the year, at which time I will introduce a new portfolio with a strong discretionary component, as I outlined last week.

This week Portfolio A1 swaps BRIC telecoms by saying goodbye to Moscow-based Mobile TeleSystems OJSC (MBT) and replacing it with Brasil Telecom Participacoes (BRP), an ADR that the discretionary trader in me likes a great deal. There are no other changes to the portfolio this week.

A snapshot of the portfolio is as follows: